Sooooo wrong, or Soooo right?

Janice, from Life Begins at Thirty, Right, sent me a link to the following bean bag chair, on sale at HomeSav  (she knows I have bean bags on the brain right now)

I LOVE IT!  I think it would be sooo comfy in the basement...We could put it where the teak chairs are...an extra seat!  (I think only one would fit)

I need a second, and third, and fourth opinion (and fifth)!  Round slouchy poufy on the floor bean bag in some sort of neutral color (the classic bean bag?)? Or this large acid green square bean bag - On sale?  Or "STEP AWAY FROM THE BEAN BAGS"

ps...I am nervous that it will be scratchy outdoor fabric, not soft buttery melt-into-me fabric